Who’s Illegal? The Politics of Immigration - For every Minuteman who beats his chest at the border, there are many more immigration rights supporters.

“Unfortunately, the history of the United States as popularized on TV or classrooms seems like it was made by Disney,” explains journalist Roberto Lovato, who’s written on the subject for diverse publications like The Nation, Los Angeles Times and more, and also served as executive director of the Central American Resource Center (CARECEN), one of America’s largest immigrant rights organizations. “It’s not real. We talk a lot about the Holocaust, but we don’t talk about Native Americans. There’s no Holocaust museum for them. We don’t have an Ellis Island for the black slaves. Most of the slaves came through Sullivan’s Island, and it should be a monument, but it’s not. A sense of history is profoundly and institutionally lacking, and so you’re going to have a population that looks at this treatment of immigrants as natural.”

Such a permissive attitude toward criminalization has led to everything from the boom in the immigrant security complex, which has turned into a billion-dollar bonanza, to the tacit endorsement of militias like The Minuteman Project, whose border patrols and presence at immigrant rights protests and rallies has caused no shortage of damage and controversy.

But for every so-called Minuteman who has showed up to inflate patriotism or disrupt undocumented day laborers at work, it seems there have been many more immigration rights supporters, including groups such as The Center for Community Change, The Coalition For Humane Immigrant Rights, Immigrant Legal Resource Center, Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition, International ANSWER, Brown Berets, and many more. That imbalance mirrors the national battle over immigration criminalization; indeed, most election-year polls have shown that the public doesn’t rate immigration as a higher priority for candidates than other topics, such as the economy or the Iraq war.”*

Stumble it! | |

Other posts that may interest you

News: Group aims to recruit Minuteman youth - Southern California

Border Security an Issue for GOP

Outside View: Cry, the beloved border

Minuteman executive director speaks in Indio - California

Bush OKs 700-mile U.S.-Mexico fence (I have to say that this is pure folly, they don't even know how much it is going to cost - show me the money)

Mexican fighting illegal immigration becomes a target - Rosanna Pulido - Illinois

Somehow, I was cc'd on an e-mail from a California Minuteman. Worth a quick look, me thinks.

Senators Hammer Out Immigration Details

Minuteman supporters protest at Columbia University - New York

The Hutchinson Report: Is Illegal Immigration Impacting Black Joblessness? If So, It’s Not the Only Factor